The $150,000 Surprise Waiting in Your Family’s Cabin
There’s a moment that happens at a lot of family lake properties, usually near the end of a long weekend. Someone looks out at the water and says something like, “This place has to stay in the family.” Everyone nods. Nobody says anything else, and that’s usually where the planning ends.
Central and Eastern Canada calls it the cottage. Here in the West, we call it the cabin. Different word, same problem. It’s the property nobody wants to talk about losing, and the one families are least prepared to actually keep.
I understand the hesitation. This isn’t just a line item to most families. It’s where the kids learned to swim, where someone taught everyone to play crib at that same table, where the same board games have lived in the same cupboard for thirty years. Talking about what happens to it after Mom and Dad are gone feels like inviting the ending into the room.
But here’s what I see over and over. The families who avoid the conversation don’t protect the cottage. They just hand their kids a hard decision and a tax bill nobody warned them about.
The tax bill that shows up uninvited
Canada doesn’t have an inheritance tax, and that fact alone convinces a lot of families the cottage passes down free and clear. But it doesn’t work that way.
When someone dies, the CRA treats them as having sold everything they owned at fair market value the moment before death, even though nothing actually sold. It’s called a deemed disposition, and for a property that’s been in the family for decades, the number can be a shock.
Say your parents bought a lake property in 1985 for $120,000, and it’s worth $850,000 today. That’s a $730,000 capital gain sitting on their final tax return. Half of it, $365,000, gets added to their income for that year. Depending on the province and their other income, the tax owing can land somewhere between $160,000 and $200,000. Sometimes more.
And here’s the part that catches families off guard: that bill comes due before anyone inherits anything. If the estate doesn’t have the cash, something has to be sold to cover it. Often, that something is the cabin itself. The family doesn’t lose it because anyone wanted to sell. They lose it because nobody planned for the tax.
Raymond and his two sisters inherited the family cabin at Sylvan Lake when their mother passed. Their parents bought it for $95,000 in the early nineties. It appraised at $780,000. The accountant walked Raymond through the final return: the deemed disposition put over $340,000 of taxable income on his mother’s last filing, and the estate owed roughly $150,000 in tax. The estate’s bank accounts held about $60,000. The siblings had ninety days to come up with the difference or list the cabin. They listed the cabin.
The part parents don’t expect: the kids may not even want it
Here’s something I’ve noticed working with families over the years; it’s usually the parents who are attached to the cottage, not the kids.
The parents built the memories there. They spent thirty summers doing the dock repairs, the dinners, the traditions. To them, the cottage is the family. But their adult kids often have a different life entirely. One lives across the country. Another has a young family and no time for property upkeep two hours away. A third genuinely loves the place but can’t afford a third of the taxes and the new septic system it’s going to need.
Parents assume the kids will want what they wanted. Often, they won’t, not in the same way. And that gap between what Mom and Dad hope for and what the next generation actually has the time, money, or desire for is where a lot of these plans fall apart. It’s worth having that conversation honestly, before it’s written into a will as a foregone conclusion.
The fallacies that cost families the most
Fear makes a terrible planner. When the capital gains changes were proposed back in 2024, I watched families rush into decisions based on headlines. Some of those decisions can’t be undone. So let’s clear up the myths doing the most damage.
“The new higher capital gains rate means we have to act now.” No. The proposed increase to the inclusion rate was cancelled entirely in March 2025. The rate is still 50%, right where it’s been for years. If you’re reading advice from 2024 that references a 66.67% inclusion rate, it’s describing rules that never took effect. Families who transferred properties in a panic during that window triggered real tax bills to dodge a change that never happened.
“We’ll just gift it to the kids and skip the tax.” The CRA doesn’t recognize gifting as a way around capital gains. Any transfer below fair market value is treated as if it happened at fair market value. Gift the cabin to your daughter today, and you owe tax on the full gain today, exactly as if you’d sold it to a stranger. Gifting only changes the timing, not the bill.
“We renovated constantly, so the gain can’t be that big.” Renovations reduce the gain, but only capital improvements count: a new roof, an addition, a rebuilt dock. Painting, repairs, and general maintenance don’t. And the burden of proof is on you. The CRA routinely denies cost base increases that aren’t backed by receipts. Thirty years of improvements with no paperwork looks, to the CRA, like thirty years of nothing.
“Adding the kids to the title avoids all of this.” Putting children on title as joint owners can sidestep probate, but the transfer itself usually triggers a partial capital gain right away. It also exposes the cabin to your kids’ lives: their creditors, their divorces, their financial troubles. A cabin on your son’s title becomes an asset in your son’s divorce.
The planning tools that actually work
None of this means the cabin is doomed. It means it needs a plan, and real options exist.
Life insurance sized to the tax bill. For a lot of families, this is the simplest fix. A policy that pays out on the second parent’s death, sized to cover the estimated capital gains tax, gives the estate the cash to pay CRA without selling anything. The cabin stays. It’s not glamorous, but it solves the exact problem that forces most sales.
Trusts, with eyes open. Parents over 65 can move a property into certain trusts without triggering immediate tax, which buys time and control. But trusts come with a built-in deadline: a deemed disposition every 21 years. A trust isn’t a way to avoid the tax forever. It’s a way to choose when and how the family deals with it.
Gradual transfer. Transferring partial interests to adult children over several years spreads the gain across multiple tax years, often at lower rates than one lump hit on a final return. It takes discipline and good advice, but it turns one crushing bill into several manageable ones.
The principal residence question. Families with a city home and a cabin get to choose which property the exemption shelters, year by year. If the cabin has grown in value faster than the house, designating the cabin may save more tax. That’s a calculation worth doing with a professional before the will gets finalized, not a guess.
The fight nobody plans for
Money is only half of it. The other half is what happens between the kids once the cottage actually lands on their plate.
Leave it to three siblings equally, without any framework, and you haven’t given them a gift. You’ve given them a negotiation, at the worst possible time, with no rules attached.
The courts are full of these stories. Verbal promises about who gets the cottage. Title transferred to some kids and not others. Wills that never mention the arrangement everyone assumed was understood. These cases drag on for years, cost tens of thousands in legal fees, and end relationships that a single signed document could have saved.
Keiko’s parents wanted their Muskoka cottage to go to all three kids. Instead of just writing it into the will, her father asked the three of them to draft a sharing agreement first: who pays what, who gets which weeks, what happens if someone wants out. Keiko and her older brother had a working draft in a month. Her younger brother read it and admitted he didn’t actually want the cottage. He wanted the equivalent value from the estate instead. It made for an awkward dinner. It was also the cheapest dispute resolution the family ever paid for, because it happened while their parents were alive and could still adjust the will.
That’s the strategy I like best: have the next generation draft the co-ownership agreement themselves, before anything transfers. If they can’t agree on paper while everyone’s healthy and talking, they won’t agree at the lawyer’s office after a funeral. And if the exercise reveals that one kid doesn’t actually want the cabin, that’s not a failure. That’s the plan doing its job.
A good agreement covers cost sharing, a usage schedule, how repairs get decided, what happens when someone wants out, and how disputes get settled.
Where you live changes the math
The province matters too. Here in Alberta, there’s no estate administration tax, just flat court fees capped at a few hundred dollars regardless of estate size. An Ontario family with the same cottage faces probate fees of roughly 1.5% of the estate’s value, which is why Ontario cottage owners often use strategies like multiple wills that make no sense out here. Quebec runs on different concepts entirely. Advice that’s perfect in one province can be pointless in another, so make sure whoever’s guiding you knows the rules where the property actually sits.
If your family keeps avoiding or circling this conversation without landing anywhere, The Will Blueprint™ walks you through exactly the decisions above, who inherits, how it’s structured, what to flag for your lawyer. You’ll walk into that appointment with your thinking done and your questions ready, instead of paying hourly rates to figure out what you want. Find it with all my planning tools at nexsteps.ca/tools/.
The cabin holds the family’s best memories. It shouldn’t hold its worst fight. The families who keep it for another generation aren’t the luckiest ones or the richest ones. They’re the ones who had the conversation honestly, memories and all, and then kept talking after everyone came in off the dock.
Visit our services page to see how we can help.
Watch our video here, or watch on our YouTube Channel:
Prefer a podcast? Listen here!
Please send us your questions or share your comments.
Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and is not legal, financial, medical, or tax advice.