Most Executors Don’t Know They Can Be Paid
Most people who agree to be an executor do it out of love, loyalty, or a sense of obligation. It feels like the right thing to do. It rarely feels like a job. But it is a job. And in Canada, it’s a job you’re legally entitled to be paid for.
That surprises a lot of people. It surprises the executors who didn’t know they could claim compensation, and it surprises the beneficiaries who didn’t know it was coming out of the estate. Both of those surprises can create real problems. And both of them are preventable.
What The Law Says
In every common law province across Canada, the law recognizes that administering an estate is a significant responsibility and that executors are entitled to fair and reasonable compensation for their work. The legal language varies by province, but the principle is consistent from coast to coast.
That compensation is paid from the estate, before assets are distributed to beneficiaries. It isn’t a gift, and it isn’t negotiated after the fact as a favour. It’s a recognized entitlement, grounded in legislation, and supported by decades of case law.
The general guideline most provinces reference is up to 5% of the estate’s total value, though that number requires some explanation. It isn’t a flat rate, it isn’t guaranteed, and it isn’t the same in every province.
How Compensation Is Actually Calculated
The 5% figure is a guideline, not a rule. Courts and beneficiaries look at compensation based on what’s fair given the actual work involved.
In Ontario, the commonly referenced benchmark is the Five Percent Rule. Under the Trustee Act, courts apply guidelines of 2.5% on capital receipts, 2.5% on capital disbursements, 2.5% on revenue receipts, and 2.5% on revenue disbursements, which combines to roughly 5% of the estate’s total value. An additional care and management fee of 0.4% annually on the average estate value may apply if the estate holds assets requiring ongoing management.
In British Columbia, the range is generally 3% to 5% of the estate’s value, with an additional 0.4% care and management fee available for estates where assets are managed over an extended period.
In Alberta, the Surrogate Rules Committee has published suggested guidelines (not legally binding, but commonly used as a reference). These guidelines suggest 3% to 5% on the first $250,000 of estate capital, 2% to 4% on the next $250,000, and 0.5% to 3% on amounts beyond that. Courts look at a range of factors including the time spent, the complexity of the estate, the skill required, and the result achieved.
Across all provinces, what remains constant is this: compensation is assessed based on the work done, not just the size of the estate. A large but simple estate may warrant less than a smaller but complicated one.
These guidelines apply to family members and individuals serving as executor. Professional executors such as trust companies or law firms typically charge according to their own published fee schedules, which are often higher and may include additional charges for specific services.
What Most Family Executors Actually Do
Here’s what’s true in practice: most family members who serve as executor don’t claim compensation. Some don’t know they’re entitled to it. Some feel it would be inappropriate given that they’re also a beneficiary. Some simply don’t want to have the conversation.
None of those reasons make the entitlement disappear. And all of them can create complications later.
When no one has discussed compensation in advance, the executor’s decision about whether to claim it or waive it can catch beneficiaries off guard either way. If they claim it, beneficiaries who weren’t expecting a deduction from the estate may feel blindsided, or worse, suspicious. If they waive it without saying so, the implicit expectation can gradually build into resentment if the administration turns out to be far more demanding than anyone anticipated.
When Helen Said No
Helen was named executor for her mother’s estate, a role she accepted without hesitation. She told herself she wouldn’t take compensation. It felt wrong to profit from her mother’s death, and her two siblings were the other beneficiaries. She said nothing about it at the time.
Eighteen months later, after dealing with a contested family property, two rounds of tax filings, multiple beneficiary disagreements, and a process that consumed hundreds of hours of her time and significant personal stress, Helen deeply regretted not having that conversation at the start. She still didn’t take the compensation. But she wished someone had told her what she was entitled to, and what it was worth to say so clearly, before resentment had time to take root.
The Tax Piece Nobody Mentions
There’s an important tax consideration that often doesn’t come up until after the fact: executor compensation is taxable income.
If you receive compensation as executor, it needs to be reported on your personal tax return for the year you receive it. The estate is required to issue a T4A slip showing the total amount paid. The income is taxed at your marginal rate, just like employment income.
This has practical implications. An executor who is also a beneficiary needs to understand that receiving an inheritance is generally tax-free, while receiving executor compensation is not. If you’re also a residual beneficiary, waiving your compensation doesn’t change what the will says but it does mean the residue of the estate increases, which flows to all residual beneficiaries according to the will. Depending on your share of the residue and your personal tax situation, that outcome may work in your favour. It’s worth talking through with a tax professional before you decide.
Expenses, however, are a completely separate matter. Out-of-pocket costs incurred while administering the estate (mileage, filing fees, postage, professional services) are reimbursable from the estate regardless of whether the executor takes compensation. Executors should never waive reimbursement of legitimate expenses, even when they choose not to claim a fee.
When Compensation Becomes A Dispute
Executor compensation is one of the most common sources of conflict in estate administration. That’s not because executors are greedy or beneficiaries are unreasonable. It’s because the conversation almost never happens at the right time.
Disputes tend to follow a predictable pattern. The executor says nothing about compensation during the administration. Beneficiaries assume they’ll receive a certain amount from the estate. When the final accounting is presented and a compensation claim appears, beneficiaries feel surprised or deceived, even when the claim is entirely appropriate.
The opposite happens too. An executor does a significant amount of work, chooses not to claim compensation out of a sense of duty, and starts to feel that their contribution went unrecognized. That resentment can outlast the estate by years.
Both outcomes are avoidable. The answer isn’t a particular dollar figure. It’s transparency, early in the process.
When the Numbers Didn’t Match
David was executor for his aunt’s estate. The will made no mention of compensation, and no conversation had ever taken place. He administered the estate carefully over twenty three months, dealing with a rental property, three financial institutions, and a beneficiary dispute that required legal advice.
When he submitted his final accounting with a compensation claim of just under 3% of the estate’s value, two of the three beneficiaries objected. The resulting negotiation added months to an already lengthy process and left relationships strained, not because David was wrong, but because no one had said anything when it would have been easier to hear it.
What This Means If You’ve Been Named Executor
If you’re being asked to serve as executor, or if you’ve already agreed, these are the conversations worth having sooner rather than later.
- Find out whether the will addresses compensation. Some wills set a specific amount or percentage. Some say compensation is at the executor’s discretion. Some say nothing at all. Knowing which situation you’re in changes how you approach the conversation with beneficiaries.
- Be transparent with beneficiaries early. If you intend to claim compensation, say so at the beginning of the administration, not the end. You don’t need to name a figure immediately, but an early acknowledgment that compensation is being considered gives everyone time to adjust their expectations.
- Keep records of your time and work. Even if you’re not sure yet whether you’ll claim anything, document what you’re doing. Time logs, notes on decisions made, professional advice sought: all of it supports a compensation claim if you decide to make one, and all of it demonstrates prudent administration if the claim is ever questioned.
- Understand the tax implications before you decide. Executor compensation is taxable income, while an inheritance you receive as a beneficiary is generally not. If you’re also a beneficiary of the estate, talk to a tax professional before deciding whether to claim compensation. Waiving it doesn’t change what the will says, but it does mean the residue available to all residual beneficiaries increases, which may work in your favour depending on your tax situation.
If you’re in the planning stage and want to make sure your will handles executor compensation clearly, our Planning Toolkit is a good place to start. The tools are designed to help you work through the details at your own pace, specific to your jurisdiction.
What This Means If You’re Writing A Will
This is the piece that gets overlooked most often on the planning side: the will is the right place to address executor compensation, and most wills don’t do it.
Naming someone as executor without addressing compensation puts them in an uncomfortable position. It forces a conversation that most family members would rather avoid, at a time when they’re already under pressure. It leaves room for misunderstanding. And it creates the potential for a dispute that could’ve been prevented with one straightforward clause.
You don’t have to specify an exact amount. You can set a percentage, a flat fee, a direction to follow provincial guidelines, or simply acknowledge that compensation is appropriate and leave the amount to the executor’s reasonable judgment with beneficiary consent. Any of these is better than silence.
If the executor is a close family member who you expect will waive compensation, it’s still worth acknowledging the entitlement in the will. Giving them the option and saying explicitly that they may accept or waive it respects their time and removes any awkwardness from the decision.
You Said Yes. Here’s What That’s Worth.
Estate administration isn’t light work. It involves financial responsibility, legal obligations, tax filings, beneficiary communication, and decision-making under pressure, often while grieving, often while managing family dynamics that were complicated long before the estate came into the picture.
The compensation isn’t a windfall. It’s recognition that the person in that role did something significant, and that their time, judgment, and accountability had real value.
Whether you take it, waive it, or address it in your will before the question ever arises, understanding what you’re entitled to and what others may expect is part of handling the role well.
Visit our services page to see how we can help.
Watch our video here, or watch on our YouTube Channel:
Prefer a podcast? Listen here!
Please send us your questions or share your comments.
Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and is not legal, financial, medical, or tax advice.
