Wills and Wounds: The Emotional Fallout of Disinheritance

When writing a will, emotions often run high, and decisions about who should inherit and disinheritance can be influenced by a range of factors—from strained relationships to personal grievances. However, the choice to cut someone, especially a child, out of a will can have lasting consequences on your legacy. Before cutting someone out of your will, be sure to examine closely the reasons for doing it and the potential long term effects on those who you have chosen to disinherit.  Let’s take a look at some of the reasons testators may exclude heirs, the emotional and legal fallout, and how to safeguard your legacy even after you’re gone.

Why Do Testators Cut People Out of Their Will?

Disinheriting someone from a will is not a decision that should be made lightly. Emotions rather than deep reflection often run this decision. Common reasons include:

• Family Conflicts: Long-standing disagreements or estrangements can lead to a testator deciding to exclude a family member.
• Perceived Injustice: A testator may feel that one child or relative has received more during their lifetime and choose to balance the scales.
• Influence of Others: Sometimes, a new spouse or family member may influence the testator’s decisions, leading to the exclusion of others.
• Personal Beliefs: A testator might disapprove of a child’s lifestyle or choices and decide to exclude them from the will.

The Emotional Impact on Those Left Out

Being excluded from a will can be an incredibly painful experience, particularly for children. For many, inheritance is more than just a transfer of assets; it represents a final act of love, validation, and connection. When someone is unexpectedly left out of a will, it can trigger deep feelings of abandonment and rejection, leading to lasting emotional scars.

• Feelings of Rejection: Children who are disinherited often grapple with questions about their worth and the nature of their relationship with the deceased. They may feel as though their entire bond was conditional, leading to a sense of profound betrayal.
• Resentment and Bitterness: The decision to exclude someone can fuel feelings of resentment not only towards the testator but also towards other heirs who were included. This can cause lasting rifts within families, turning what should be a time of grieving and remembrance into a period of conflict and animosity.
• Unresolved Grief: Grieving a loved one is already a challenging process, but when coupled with the shock of disinheritance, it can become even more complicated. The grieving process may be stalled or prolonged as the disinherited individual struggles to come to terms with both the loss and the perceived injustice.
• Legacy of Division: The emotional toll of exclusion often reverberates through the generations. Siblings who might have otherwise supported each other through the grieving process may find themselves divided, leading to a fractured family unit and a legacy of discord.

Legal Ramifications of Exclusion

Disinheriting someone, especially a child or close family member, can lead to significant legal challenges that may consume both time and financial resources, potentially diminishing the estate and creating public disputes. Here are some of the potential legal consequences and fallout.

• Contesting the Will: In many jurisdictions, children and spouses have the legal right to contest a will if they believe they have been unfairly excluded. Common grounds for contesting include claims of undue influence, where the testator was pressured into making decisions, or lack of mental capacity, where the testator was not of sound mind when drafting the will.
• Undue Influence and Legal Battles: If a testator was influenced by a new spouse or another individual to exclude a child, the disinherited party might argue that the will does not reflect the testator’s true intentions. Legal battles over such claims can be lengthy and emotionally draining, often resulting in the erosion of family relationships and the depletion of estate funds.
• Public Disclosure: When a will is contested, the details become part of the public record, exposing private family matters to public scrutiny. This not only tarnishes the testator’s reputation but can also exacerbate the pain of the disinherited party, who might feel further humiliated and wronged.
• Estate Depletion: Legal disputes over a contested will can quickly deplete the assets of the estate, leaving little for any of the heirs. Lawyers’ fees, court costs, and the potential for a drawn-out battle can reduce the value of the estate significantly, meaning the intentions behind the exclusion might be moot if there’s little left to distribute.

Impact on Legacy: What Will You Be Remembered For?

A person’s legacy is more than just the assets they leave behind; it’s also the memories, values, and emotional impact they impart to their loved ones, business associates and acquaintances. When someone is excluded from a will, particularly a child, it can profoundly affect how the testator is remembered.  Some of the ways that disinheriting someone can change the way you are remembered include the following.

• Legacy of Bitterness: The decision to exclude a child can overshadow all other aspects of the testator’s life and legacy. Instead of being remembered for their love, generosity, or achievements, the testator might be remembered for the pain they caused by excluding someone from their will. This can taint the memories of the deceased, turning what should be a celebration of their life into a reflection on their final, divisive act.
• Family Disunity: Disinheriting a family member often creates rifts that last for generations. The bitterness and division sown by such decisions can prevent families from healing, leading to ongoing disputes and a fractured family tree. Instead of leaving a legacy of unity and love, the testator might be responsible for deepening family divisions.
• Reputation After Death: The way a will is executed can influence how others outside the family view the deceased. A will that disinherits a child may lead others to question the testator’s fairness or mental state, potentially casting a shadow over their entire life’s work and reputation.
• Loss of Positive Influence: By excluding someone, the testator loses the opportunity to positively influence their life after death. An inheritance, even a small one, can serve as a final gesture of reconciliation, an olive branch that encourages healing and remembrance. Without it, the testator’s influence ends on a note of estrangement rather than connection.

Safeguarding Your Legacy: Alternatives to Exclusion

Cutting someone out of your will can have long lasting repercussions.  So before deciding to take this step, consider these alternatives:

• Open Communication: Have honest conversations with your heirs about your decisions. Clear communication can prevent misunderstandings and reduce the likelihood of disputes.
• Conditional Bequests: Instead of outright exclusion, consider leaving a conditional bequest that encourages certain behaviors or achievements.
• Letter of Explanation: Accompany your will with a letter explaining your reasons. While not legally binding, it can provide closure and reduce the emotional impact on those left out.
• Seek Professional Guidance: Consulting with a legal professional can help you structure your will in a way that minimizes potential disputes while honoring your wishes.

From the Grave: The Lasting Impact of Disinheritance

Deciding to exclude someone from your will, especially a child, can have far-reaching consequences that extend beyond the grave. It’s essential to weigh the emotional, legal, and familial impact of such a decision and explore alternatives that allow you to maintain your legacy while achieving your goals. By making thoughtful choices, you can ensure that your legacy is one of love, respect, and peace, rather than conflict and division.

A Certified Executor Advisor (CEA) can play a crucial role in this process by offering expert guidance on how to structure your will in a way that reflects your true intentions while minimizing potential disputes. They can help you navigate the complex emotions and legalities involved, ensuring that your legacy is preserved and your loved ones are cared for according to your wishes. Consulting with a CEA can make all the difference in leaving behind a positive and lasting legacy.

Nancy Boisvert is a CEA.  To see our programs or to make an appointment for an initial consultation, be sure to visit our online store for programs and guides. 

Watch our video here, or watch on our YouTube Channel:

Prefer a podcast?  Listen here!

Your questions and comments are always welcome! Contact us to learn more.